The Selection Before the Election
In some parts of India, the real contest ends before anyone votes. It is decided at the scrutiny table, at the withdrawal deadline, in a proposer's living room, or at a family dinner where two brothers split two party tickets. An unopposed seat may look like strength. In reality, it is a verdict that no one can read: not the voter, not the analyst, and least of all the party that won.
ELECTIONSDEMOCRACYPOLITICAL STRATEGYCONGRESSBJPPOLITICAL COMMUNICATIONPOLITICSINDIAN POLITICSECIINDIA


On 10 November, the last day to withdraw nominations in Tripura's civic polls, 77 of 345 wards were settled. Nobody voted in those wards, and nobody will. On 27 November, people in those wards will see their neighbours queue at the booth while they stay home, not by choice, but because they have no option. There is no one on their ballot to choose. The opposition says its candidates were threatened into withdrawing. The State Election Commissioner says the complaints are baseless. Either way, the result is the same. Seventy-seven councillors have been elected by a deadline and not by voters.
This is not a Tripura story. It is one of the oldest and least examined habits in Indian politics, and every party that has ever been strong enough has practised some version of it.
Withdrawal day, not counting day
Everyone watches counting day. The anchors, the graphics, the leads and trails. We practitioners watch a quieter date on the calendar: the last day to withdraw nominations.
That is the day you find out what kind of election it will really be. You see who filed and who was persuaded not to. You see whose papers survived scrutiny and whose did not. Sometimes an independent suddenly has a family commitment. Sometimes a rival candidate appears at a press conference wearing a gamcha and a cap in a new party's colours. By the time the EVMs are switched on, in some seats, the choice has already been made for the voter by people the voter will never meet. What happens in those seats is not an election. It is a selection.
There are only a handful of ways to do it. Fear. The fix. Courtesy. Money. And, most elegantly, the family.
The weakest link is not the candidate
A candidate can be brave. Most of the time, in a contested seat, he has to be. But his nomination does not rest on his courage alone. It rests on his proposers.
The proposer is not a politician. He might be a neighbour, a schoolteacher, a shopkeeper, or a cousin. His name goes on a public document saying he supports this person. He gets no security and no party protection once the counting is over. He lives in the same lane as the people he has just crossed, and he will still be there long after the candidate has moved on.
In Surat in 2024, the Congress candidate's nomination died because three of his proposers said the signatures on his form were not theirs. His substitute's papers died the same way. Eight others withdrew, and the seat was declared without a vote. In Kannur last year, a proposer for an opposition candidate was recorded explaining why he could not stand by his signature: "What if something happens? Should I suffer that too?" A local leader put it more simply: "We have voters, but no one was willing to step forward."
It is easy to call that cowardice, but it is not. It is the most rational calculation anyone in the process makes. The candidate may get a ticket, a career, or a seat. The proposer gets only the risk. Any system that puts the most exposed person at the front door should not be surprised when contests are lost there, long before polling day.
Fear and the fix belong to everyone
No party gets to be pious about this.
In Bengal's 2018 panchayat polls, about a third of all gram panchayat seats had only one candidate, from the ruling Trinamool. In one district, every zilla parishad seat but one went the same way. The previous record had been about one in ten. In Kannur, the CPI(M) has run a municipality where, one year, half the wards were never contested. In Arunachal in 2024, ten BJP candidates, including the Chief Minister, were declared elected before a single vote was cast. And if you go back far enough, the party with the most unopposed Lok Sabha members in Indian history is the Congress, from the decades when it was the only game in town.
The methods are different. Sometimes there is a crowd outside a candidate's house. Sometimes a signature is suddenly denied by its owner. Sometimes there is a last-minute withdrawal, followed by a photo in new party colours. The outcome is always the same. A citizen who would have voted does not get to.
Not every walkover is a fix. In September, in Tripura's tribal council areas, TIPRA Motha won more than a thousand village committee seats unopposed, about a quarter of the total, helped by an ally, the BJP, that fielded candidates in fewer than half the seats, and an opposition that could not cover the rest. The reports carried no complaint of intimidation. That looks like arithmetic, not fear. But the voters in those seats were still left with one name. The question to ask of any walkover is not how many. It is why.
Indore, where the verdict leaked out
There is only one place I know where you could actually see how voters responded to being managed.
In Indore in 2024, the Congress candidate withdrew on the last day and joined the BJP. Unlike Surat, the seat was not uncontested. Smaller candidates stayed in. So voters still had a ballot, and on the EVM was a button marked None of the Above.
More than two lakh people pressed it. This was the highest NOTA count ever recorded in a Lok Sabha seat. On the same day, in the same seat, the BJP candidate won by the largest margin in the country. Two records in one constituency. The party got its landslide, but the voters still had the last word in the only way left to them.
That is what a walkover hides. When there is a ballot, the verdict comes out. When there is not, it stays hidden.
A verdict nobody can read
This is the cruelty of an unopposed seat. It does not just deny the voter a choice. It also destroys the only way to record what she thought.
You cannot measure a vote that was never cast. You cannot compare it with the ward next door, because that is a different place with different voters. You cannot poll it later, because people frightened out of a contest will not tell a stranger with a clipboard. The Supreme Court, hearing a challenge after Surat, put it clearly. It asked whether the "invisible will" of voters who would have rejected a sole candidate should be allowed to disappear.
That is what a party gets with a walkover. Not strength, but blindness. It has won a seat and made sure it will never find out what that seat thinks of it.
Sometimes, there are clues later. Bengal's walkovers in 2018 were followed a year later by a sharp drop in the ruling party's Lok Sabha seats, and voters who had been shut out of the panchayat polls told reporters that this was why they switched. The Left's uncontested wards in Kannur last November were followed a month later by its worst local body result since the mid-1990s, and in May by the loss of Keralam itself, even as its strongholds held. I would not call any of that proof. Too much else was happening. But I have never seen a party grow stronger by taking the vote away from people who would have used it.
When the state pays a village not to vote
Fear and the fix at least happen in the dark. The strangest version of the uncontested election happens in daylight, run by governments and funded by public money.
It started in Gujarat more than two decades ago under the gentle name samras, meaning harmony. A village that elects its panchayat unanimously, with no contest, gets a grant. Last year, more than seven hundred Gujarat panchayats were rewarded this way, sharing about thirty-five crore rupees. The idea has spread to governments of every colour. Andhra Pradesh in 2021 offered up to twenty lakh rupees per village for unanimous results, in the name of "peace and harmony". Punjab gave five lakh rupees each to more than three thousand panchayats that skipped the vote in 2024.
Last November, Bandi Sanjay Kumar, a Union minister from Telangana, went even further. He offered ten lakh rupees to villages in his Karimnagar constituency that unanimously elected BJP-backed candidates, and warned that if candidates from other parties won, "new funds will not come".
That last step is not an accident. It is where the logic was always heading. Once the state agrees to pay for consensus, it is a short step to a party paying for its own.
The defence of these schemes is not foolish. Village elections can be extremely bitter. Factions harden, families stop speaking, and sometimes people get hurt. A quiet consensus can spare a village from all of that. I have seen those fights up close, and no one who has would wish them on a village.
But the evidence on what paid consensus actually produces is not encouraging. A study of Gujarat's own panchayats found that bigger grants did exactly what they were meant to do: fewer candidates and more unopposed seats. Then, the councils elected that way spent far less of the money they controlled, and fewer Dalit and Adivasi households got work under the rural employment scheme. The councils answered to those who arranged the consensus, not to the people who were asked to stay quiet.
That is the real cost, and it is not paid at the next election. It is paid every day in between, in roads, wages, and attention.
I believe these schemes should be stopped everywhere, by every government that uses them. The state can encourage people to vote, but it should not pay them not to. If a consensus needs a cheque, it is not really a consensus. It is a purchase. The cost is paid by those who want to stand but are told the village cannot afford it. That is rarely the landlord. More often, it is the young man from the wrong lane, the woman on a reserved seat, or the Dalit candidate whose name would have upset the so-called harmony. If violence is the concern, the solution is to police it, not to take away the vote. You cannot fix the bitterness of elections by buying them off.
If governments want to reward villages, there are plenty of better reasons. Reward a gram sabha that truly meets, a social audit that people actually read, or accounts that are made public. Villages should be rewarded for how they govern, never for skipping the vote.
The same pot
There is another way to take away a voter's choice, and it might seem the most polite. You offer a contest, but make sure it does not matter who wins.
In Madhya Pradesh's Hoshangabad constituency in 2023, the BJP chose a former Speaker of the state assembly as its candidate. The Congress picked his brother, who had left the BJP that same year after not getting a ticket. The winner described it as a battle of ideologies, Karna versus Arjuna. But a local voter put it: "Ghee toh ek hi matka mein jayega." The ghee ends up in the same pot, no matter who wins.
In Haryana's Tosham, a year later, two grandchildren of a former Chief Minister ran against each other for the family seat, each from a different party. Across the state, members of three major political families competed in nine seats, sometimes even against each other.
For the family, this is a perfect safety net. No matter which party wins, the seat stays in the family, and they keep connections in both parties. For voters, it looks like a real contest, but there is no real choice. Add to this the dummy candidate with the same name as the rival, something the Kerala High Court recently called a "massacre of democracy", and the by-poll courtesy, where parties agree not to compete, and you start to see how many elections in India are settled by deals long before the public gets a say.
Count the withdrawals
So what should we do about this?
Before a party celebrates a walkover, it should ask itself three questions. Why did no one else stand? Would we have won if someone had? And where will the voters we ignored go when they finally have another option?
If the opposition cannot protect its proposers, it does not truly have candidates. Proposers deserve as much care as the candidates themselves: backup papers filed early, names not left alone in their neighbourhoods, and a party that remembers them even after the results.
The rest of us should also change what we pay attention to. The Supreme Court has asked the government to consider if anyone should be able to enter Parliament by default, without winning even a small share of the vote. No matter how that question is answered, the habit it highlights is clear: count the withdrawals, not just the results. I think the most important number in some Indian elections is not the winning margin, but how many people were kept off the ballot.
A vote that was never cast is not a lost vote. It is a vote still waiting.
